Why Nvidia Trades Cheaper Than the S&P 500 for the First Time in 13 Years

Nvidia’s stock just hit a valuation milestone that hasn’t happened since 2013. According to The Information, the world’s most important AI chipmaker now looks “cheap” by traditional metrics, and what that signals about the AI industry’s next phase deserves attention.

The numbers tell a striking story. Nvidia’s forward price-to-earnings ratio has dropped to roughly 20x, falling below the S&P 500’s average of about 23.6x. For a company that delivered $215.9 billion in annual revenue (up 65% year-over-year) and just posted Q4 data-center sales of $62.3 billion (up 75%), trading at a discount to the broader market feels counterintuitive.

But Wall Street isn’t questioning Nvidia’s present. It’s repricing Nvidia’s future.

What’s Driving the Discount

Several forces are compressing Nvidia’s valuation at once:

  • DeepSeek’s efficiency shock: The Chinese AI lab demonstrated that impressive models can be built without relying on Nvidia’s latest chips. That raised a fundamental question: what if AI training becomes more efficient faster than expected?
  • Export control uncertainty: U.S. officials opened an investigation into whether DeepSeek trained its newest model on banned Nvidia Blackwell chips, adding regulatory risk to the mix.
  • Competition from within China: DeepSeek denied Nvidia and AMD early access to its V4 model while giving Chinese chipmakers like Huawei an optimization head start.
  • The “sky-high expectations” trap: When consensus already expects 42.5% earnings growth in 2026, even strong results don’t move the needle. Nvidia has to keep beating extraordinary expectations just to hold its ground.

What stands out here is the disconnect. Fundamentals remain excellent. Nvidia disclosed a backlog exceeding $500 billion. Hyperscalers have projected somewhere between $527 billion (Goldman Sachs’ estimate) and $700 billion in combined AI capital expenditure for 2026. The demand story hasn’t broken.

Yet the stock trades like investors see a ceiling approaching.

Why This Matters Now

This valuation compression signals something bigger than one company’s stock price. The market is essentially saying: the AI infrastructure buildout’s most explosive growth phase may be closer to its peak than its beginning.

That doesn’t mean AI spending is slowing. It means investors are repricing the duration of hypergrowth. There’s a meaningful difference between “Nvidia will keep growing” and “Nvidia will keep growing at 65%+ annually for years.” The stock’s valuation now reflects the former, not the latter.

For the broader AI industry, this shift carries real implications:

  • AI startups relying on GPU access may find pricing and availability improving as the market cools expectations around chip scarcity
  • Efficiency gains matter more than ever: DeepSeek proved that algorithmic innovation can partially substitute for raw compute. Expect more investment in training efficiency, not just bigger clusters
  • China’s AI ecosystem is becoming self-sufficient faster than many anticipated, creating parallel supply chains that reduce Nvidia’s pricing power in key markets

What Comes Next

This is significant because it marks a psychological turning point. Nvidia at a discount to the S&P 500 forces a reassessment of how the market values the entire AI supply chain. If the company with the strongest competitive moat in AI hardware can’t command a premium multiple, it suggests investors want to see the next phase of AI monetization before paying up again.

The smart read: Nvidia’s business is still exceptional. But the era of the market giving AI companies unlimited benefit of the doubt on future growth is ending. From here, execution and proof of sustained demand will matter more than narrative.

For a deeper look at what Nvidia’s valuation signals for AI’s next chapter, check out the full analysis at The Information.

Scroll to Top