Man, the internet has been on FIRE since GPT-5 dropped, right? I’ve seen everything from “it’s a disaster” to “OpenAI pulled a bait and switch.” It’s been wild.
So I was super stoked when I saw a new video from an AI professional who decided to cut through the noise and actually test all the biggest complaints. The mind behind it did a deep dive to see what’s valid, what’s been fixed, and what’s just hype.
Here’s the breakdown of what the expert found:
⚙️ The Investigation
The YouTuber systematically tackled the four biggest gripes with GPT-5.
- 📌 Gripe 1: Where did the old models go?!
Everyone was furious that models like GPT-4o vanished overnight. The good news? They’re back! This industry pro shows that OpenAI listened to the feedback. You can get your favorite models back by going to Settings > General and flipping the “Show legacy models” switch. Problem solved! - 💡 Gripe 2: The personality is gone!
People felt GPT-5 was cold, robotic, and gave lazy answers. To test this, the creator ran side-by-side comparisons with GPT-4o. Honestly, the results were pretty similar. The theory is that the initial complaints were caused by a bug in the model router that OpenAI has since fixed. So, this one seems to be an invalid complaint now. - ✍️ Gripe 3: It’s worse at coding!
This is a big one. The innovator tested its coding skills by asking it and other models to build a clone of the game Balatro. The results were not great for GPT-5. An older OpenAI model (03 Pro) actually made a more functional game, and Claude’s version looked way better. The verdict here? This complaint seems totally valid. - 🤔 Gripe 4: It’s just plain dumber!
The creator threw a bunch of logic puzzles, riddles, and math problems at it. The results were a real mixed bag. It failed a simple logic puzzle about a cup and a basic algebra problem. But it correctly solved a couple of tricky riddles. Because it’s so hit-or-miss, the expert concludes this concern is also valid. You just can’t trust it 100% of the time.
✨ Prompt of the Day
I thought this part of the video was awesome. This innovator showed how to build a custom AI agent for your business with just one prompt. Here’s the exact prompt the person who shared it used to create an agent that finds interesting tech news for video ideas:
“Build me an AI agent called the tech updates analyst. Your objective each week is to research the most important and interesting updates in AI and technology. Then turn that into a clear, structured brief to guide a video script. Focus on stories that are relevant, accurate, visually appealing, and have storytelling potential.”
The Final Word
According to the video’s creator, GPT-5 was definitely overhyped, and its issues with coding and accuracy are real. But the good news is that OpenAI is listening and making fixes. It’s not a total disaster, but it’s not the world-changing leap we were promised, either.
For the full deep-dive with all the side-by-side tests and examples, make sure to watch the original video from the creator!